In today’s fast-moving financial world, borrowing money has become easier than ever. Whether it’s for a medical emergency, travel, wedding expenses, or managing cash flow, people often face one common question: loan or credit card, which is better? The two most popular borrowing options in India are personal loans and credit card loans. While both provide quick access to funds, they work very differently.
Choosing the wrong option can increase your interest burden and impact your credit score. In this article, we will compare personal loan vs credit card loan in detail to help you decide which is better for your financial needs.
What Is a Personal Loan?
A personal loan is an unsecured loan offered by banks and NBFCs for a fixed tenure and fixed interest rate. You receive the loan amount as a lump sum and repay it in monthly EMIs.
Key Features of Personal Loans
-
Fixed interest rate
-
Fixed repayment tenure (1–5 years usually)
-
Predictable monthly EMIs
-
Lower interest compared to credit card loans
-
Suitable for large expenses
Personal loans are ideal for planned expenses like home renovation, education, weddings, or debt consolidation.
What Is a Credit Card Loan?
A credit card loan is a short-term borrowing option linked to your credit card. It can be taken in two ways:
-
Spending via credit card revolving credit
-
Instant loan on credit card (pre-approved)
Key Features of Credit Card Loans
-
Very high interest rates
-
Shorter repayment period
-
Quick approval (often instant)
-
No separate documentation
-
Higher risk of debt trap
Credit card loans are usually used for emergencies or short-term needs.
Personal Loan vs Credit Card Loan: Key Differences
Understanding the differences helps answer the main question: loan or credit card, which is better?
1. Interest Rates
-
Personal Loan: 10%–24% per annum
-
Credit Card Loan: 30%–45% per annum
➡️ Personal loans are significantly cheaper.
2. Loan Amount
-
Personal Loan: ₹50,000 to ₹40 lakhs
-
Credit Card Loan: Limited to credit limit
➡️ For large expenses, personal loans are better.
3. Repayment Flexibility
-
Personal Loan: Fixed EMI, fixed tenure
-
Credit Card Loan: Minimum due option can increase interest
➡️ Credit cards feel flexible but can become expensive.
4. Approval & Disbursal
-
Personal Loan: 1–3 working days
-
Credit Card Loan: Instant
➡️ Credit card loans win in speed.
5. Impact on Credit Score
-
Personal Loan: Improves score if EMIs are paid on time
-
Credit Card Loan: High utilization can reduce score
➡️ Personal loans are safer for long-term credit health.
Loan vs Credit Card: Which Is Better for Different Needs?
Let’s break it down by situation.
For Emergency Expenses
If you need money immediately and the amount is small, a credit card loan can help. However, repayment should be quick.
Winner: Credit Card Loan (short-term only)
For Big Planned Expenses
For weddings, medical procedures, or travel, personal loans are more affordable and manageable.
Winner: Personal Loan
For Debt Consolidation
Combining multiple debts into one EMI works best with a personal loan.
Winner: Personal Loan
Read For More Blog – how to improve credit score fast in india
For Short-Term Cash Crunch
If you can repay within 30–45 days, using a credit card without revolving interest may work.
Winner: Credit Card (with discipline)
Hidden Charges You Must Know
Personal Loan Charges
-
Processing fee (1%–3%)
-
Foreclosure charges (sometimes)
-
Late payment penalty
Credit Card Loan Charges
-
High late payment fees
-
GST on interest
-
Over-limit charges
➡️ Credit card loans have more hidden costs.
Risk of Debt Trap with Credit Cards
One major reason why people ask loan vs credit card, which is better is the risk factor. Credit cards encourage minimum payment, which increases interest month after month. This can easily lead to a debt trap.
Personal loans, on the other hand, have a clear repayment structure.
Which Option Is Better for Beginners?
For beginners who are new to borrowing:
-
Personal loans are easier to manage
-
EMIs are predictable
-
Lower risk of overspending
Credit cards require strong financial discipline.
Final Verdict: Loan vs Credit Card, Which Is Better?
There is no one-size-fits-all answer, but in most cases:
Personal Loan is better for large amounts, long tenure, and lower interest.
Credit Card Loan should be used only for short-term or emergency needs.
If you are unsure, always calculate total interest cost before borrowing.
For more personal finance guides, visit myfinancemoney
FAQs – Personal Loan vs Credit Card Loan
1: Is a personal loan better than a credit card loan for emergencies?
Yes, a personal loan is usually better for emergencies when you need a larger amount and want to repay it over several months. Personal loans have lower interest rates compared to credit card loans, making them more affordable for short- to medium-term needs.
2: Which has lower interest rates in India – a personal loan or a credit card loan?
Personal loans generally have much lower interest rates than credit card loans in India. While personal loan rates usually range between 10% and 24% per year, credit card loans can charge interest of 30% to 45% or even higher.
3: Can a credit card loan negatively affect my credit score?
Yes, a credit card loan can negatively impact your credit score if you maintain high outstanding balances or make late payments. High credit utilization and missed due dates can reduce your credit score significantly.
4: When should I choose a credit card loan instead of a personal loan?
You should choose a credit card loan when you need a small amount urgently and are confident you can repay it within a short time, such as one or two months. For long-term borrowing, a personal loan is a better option.
5: Can I convert my credit card outstanding into EMIs?
Yes, most banks and credit card issuers allow you to convert your outstanding credit card balance into EMIs. This can make repayment easier, but the interest rate is still higher than that of a personal loan.
6: Which is better for long-term financial planning – a personal loan or a credit card loan?
A personal loan is better for long-term financial planning because it offers fixed EMIs, a fixed tenure, and lower interest rates. Credit card loans are more suitable for short-term use and can become expensive over time.